PDA

View Full Version : Which style do you prefer for a battle tile?



Dolmen Creative
07-11-2010, 09:38 AM
Wow, I have already learned so much about cartography and have gotten some great scripts and tools from the users here. Thank you all.

On to my quandry: if you were a battle tile consumer, which of the following 3 would be your preference?

Ascension
07-11-2010, 10:35 AM
I vote for the one on the right from a purely aesthetic point of view (I don't play) but I suspect that the shadow might make things not always line up properly so the middle might be best.

Jaxilon
07-11-2010, 10:43 AM
I chose the one in the center but I think I would prefer it with the lines of the left one. I don't care for the blaring white corners though (it may be that way to keep size down?). The first one is clean and totally functional but doesn't have much ambiance. The one on the right I can't decide if it's a raised walkway that you could fall off of or if it is wall texture being shown. Anyway, I just added this so you would know what I was thinking as I looked at them.

Cheers

Dolmen Creative
07-11-2010, 11:43 AM
You know, I never looked at it like that before. I guess it could look like a raised walkway, maybe I should add a bevel layer to the edges of the black. And the fade away is wall texture. And yes, the white is there to keep size down and to keep ink requirements low when printing out the tiles.

DevinNight
07-11-2010, 12:06 PM
one thing to consider if these are going to be tiles that players assemble and rotate is the bevel, if you add a strong beveled edge, then rotate it and match it up to a non rotated tile, the bevels will be off.
I spent most of my weekend working on something very similar to the ones above.

I like the middle one, though the white is a bit too bright, maybe a soft color there would be easier to look at.

tilt
07-12-2010, 09:21 AM
The first one the pattern tile too much. The second one with RobA's script is much nicer, now the floor look good. The white areas are very white though although I know its for printing purposes. On the last one, I like the idea of a "rock" pattern in the walls, but the fade to white suddenly draws attention to the walls instead of the floor, so get rid of that ... and then work a bit more on the rock texture and you might have a winner. But as they stand now - nr. 2 is the winner :)

LS-Jebus
07-12-2010, 09:36 AM
If the setting would be medieval-ish fantasy, then the middle one is best, because with its texture it looks more like cut stone blocks than floor tile. Along with the shading and clear borders between the floor and unused space (white) the look is appropriate and effective.

The left one just has the problem of the obvious repeating pattern, and the right one takes the focus away from the floor.

torstan
07-16-2010, 11:00 PM
I totally agree with the comments above. The last one is pretty, but it's going to be a pain to get tiles that line up well using that method (I speak from pained experience). If you want your life to be ten times easier - stick with the middle style. I also feel the white is a bit brutal.

Wannabehero
07-22-2010, 10:12 AM
I like the last one the best myself. I don't think lining up the tiles will be to much of a problem as long as you get yourself a seamless stone texture that fits the tile space exactly (shouldn't be to hard, if you need one I can send you one of mine).

For the floor texture, I personally would prefer one mid-way between the first style and the other styles. Perhaps you could take the floor texture from one of the latter styles and try putting a very minor blur on it (like 1 pixel) to make it seem deeper in the image?

EDIT:
I tiled out the last style piece and see that the texture is indeed almost seamless, and looks really good IMO. I also blurred the floor flagstone texture with a single pixel gaussian blur and I really like the look. The detail is still there, but the focus is fuzzed just enough to make it seem like background.

Meridius
07-22-2010, 06:46 PM
Since my monitor displays two styles on the first line, and the last one on a second line, I'll be gambling that the bottom one is supposed to be 'the right' image. I do not have a wide-screen monitor. :P

Anyway, if the white area's where to be black or a similar dark colour, I think I'd go for the right. Alternatively, the middle one seems fine too... though I agree that the white colour is not doing any of the styles justice.