PDA

View Full Version : *** October/November Lite Challenge VOTING - Zooming In Further ***



torstan
11-16-2010, 06:19 PM
The deadline is up on the lite challenge and it's time to vote!

This month entrants were asked to map the interior of a building from a set of silhouettes. The silhouettes could be combined or adapted, as long as it's still clear that they ere derived from the given set.

Here are the thumbnails for this month's lite challenge:


Oct / Nov Challenge Thumbs (http://www.cartographersguild.com/utilities/Thumbs/Html/Challengers_Challenge_LiteOct10.htm)

We have 5 entries this month - and please make sure to click through to geamon's entry as it's in the format of a mulitlayerd pdf - so there's no thumb for it. Once you've browsed the entries, please vote for 1 entry, and remember to rep the person you vote for as well as any entries that you particularly like.

The poll will end in 4 days.

Note that the poll is not mutli-choice and I forgot to make the voters public. As this is a single choice vote this time round I'm going to leave it as is but sorry for not making the voting names public this time round.

Larb
11-16-2010, 07:24 PM
I thought they were all really good so it was tough to choose, but I voted for the spire in the end because of the lightning and atmosphere. The little 3d image of it also helped me solidify in my mind how the building would look. I do dislike voting and "rating" people's work though, because it's rare that you can't find something great about what people make (especially here, too).

Rythal
11-16-2010, 08:17 PM
yah I went with the spire as well, though I think that with a little more mood TIlt would have been a close contender as well

RecklessEnthusiasm
11-17-2010, 01:48 AM
Larb got my vote. I just love the aesthetic and colors, and the almost hand drawn look. Good work done by all, though!

Sharpe
11-17-2010, 01:58 AM
A link to each would help. Just saying.

RecklessEnthusiasm
11-17-2010, 02:08 AM
Sharpe: In the top post, you can click the giant text link "Oct/Nov Challenge Thumbs" and it will take you to all the thumbnails, which in turn link to the full sized images and their WIP threads.

Jaxilon
11-17-2010, 02:16 AM
I think you want the Thumbnails Sharpe. I agree though, it's a bit of a pain to have to have 2 frames open so you can jump back and forth to compare.

I voted for Larb's entry because of it being totally game ready and I can use this in session right now.
I really loved RE's and the atmosphere was totally awesome but I couldn't figure how what a throne would be doing all the way up the tower almost by itself. So, bottom line, only because I couldn't figure out how I might use it I went with Larb's. (I even went to the thread to see if there was a back story for it.)
Tilt's was great looking as well but I think I would have liked a few more details within the building area itself.
Map Vand - Another great entry, I liked the hand drawn look but that dark area on the lower floor threw me off and I couldn't figure out what it was.
Gaemon's I almost missed because the thumb is all screwy (not sure what the issue is there). It seemed a bit spartan on the inside compared to some of the others although I loved the light coming in through the windows, that was great.

Nice work everyone!

tilt
11-17-2010, 03:49 AM
My vote goes to RE, love the lighting of the building and the moss between the tiles. Also the great "pillars/stones" on the outside. And once again I appologize from not being able to finish my map - I gotta win the lotteri so I can drop all that work stuff that takes up my time *lol*. Great work all :)

Redrobes
11-17-2010, 08:49 AM
I couldn't decide between map vandals and reckless so I went with reckless cos he only has one silver compass award - it was that close for me. So it came as a surprise to me that MVs entry is far behind in the vote. This is where the one vote only makes for very dramatic results. So well done again to all and don't worry if your vote count is low - its not necessarily due to it not being good.

Map Vandal
11-17-2010, 10:36 AM
Larb gets my vote. I love how clean the floorplan is.

Diamond
11-17-2010, 12:32 PM
It was a tough choice for me between RE and Tilt, but I ended up going with Tilt because I like the color scheme better, as well as the mutated Blight trees. :D

Sharpe
11-17-2010, 02:44 PM
Sharpe: In the top post, you can click the giant text link "Oct/Nov Challenge Thumbs" and it will take you to all the thumbnails, which in turn link to the full sized images and their WIP threads.

This I did not know.

Hey, I voted for you! Good thing you told me that. XD

Djekspek
11-17-2010, 05:13 PM
Great maps again people! RE's map got my vote... and of course rep for all. cheers!

geamon
11-17-2010, 05:49 PM
I voted for RE, love the ambiance. Just wish I could have completed my submission. Good work everyone!

rdanhenry
11-18-2010, 10:09 AM
Had to vote for RE's Spire as I like it in spite of it being in a style I don't usually care for.

RecklessEnthusiasm
11-22-2010, 08:21 AM
Larb - Thanks! The 3D model was a last minute add-on. It was a cinch to whip up in Sketchup, but people seem to like having that extra bit to help them visualize (In all maps, I mean, not mine). I think this is something Gameprinter learned a long time ago, as he often has one or two supplemental images on his maps, and he's gotta have somewhere near the record for challenge wins.
Jaxilon - Thanks for calling me out on that. I honestly didn't know what to put in the place--now that you mention it, I don't know why a throne would be on the top floor either.
Sharpe - No problem, my man, and Thanks. You should join in on the next challenge!
Rdanhenry - I am curious, what about this type of style do you generally not like? Do you prefer the abstract grid-paper style encounter map, or just clean lines/colors?
Gaemon - Thanks, my man. Your entry was definitely one of my favorite ones. I am surprised you wanted to pull it, actually, as I thought it looked pretty well finished.

tilt
11-22-2010, 08:51 AM
then again, there could be a million reasons for the throne to be on the top floor. Maybe the guy likes the view? I know that in Assasins Quest, the king used the highest tower to "skill" from, so a comfortable chair would have been nice there :) congrats on the victory RE :)

RecklessEnthusiasm
11-22-2010, 09:41 AM
Thanks, Tilt! Your entry was pretty rocking, too! I hope to post a more in depth C&C of the ones here when I get a chance.
Edit: Oh no, I typed out a paragraph for each and it logged me out! I lost it. Darn it! I'll see if I can retype later.

geamon
11-22-2010, 10:12 AM
If you knew what I had planned for the entire project you would udnerstand. Basically here's what I hadn't finished furnishing the 1F with a library common eating area and kitchen near the stairs down, 2F quarters for the monks, 3F priors room and office , infirmary and balcony with organs. I was going to also add a stable in the sw corner with the insides fleshed out on the 1F and roof and such on 2F. Have a sectional view mid branches of te tree on 2F and the crown of the trees of leaves on 3F. For the chapel section was going to add perspective tthe further you got up and added the windows and such in it in an isometric view. Also going to add a mist effect or glow effect on each floor that escalates the further up you get which braught previous floor elements out of focus and put enphasis on the new elements for the floors. Then top it off with a lighting scheme that made it look like sundown or dusk. Ya..... I bit off more then I could chew. Once I finish the world map I'm working on I'll finish this up.