View Full Version : RETRY, new PHOTOSHOP world map.
04-08-2012, 06:59 PM
Here's my new map made in photoshop, critisism is welcomed, as long as polite ;)
04-08-2012, 10:36 PM
I like the basic tones of the map. The two basic visual issues for me s that the rivers seem to be sitting on top of the terrain and the blue coast matching into the seems a tad off. Livable, but not ideal. The river appearing to sit on top of stuff is the bigger bugaboo to my eye. The rivers should likely also be more winding as they hit flatter terrain.
04-09-2012, 02:27 AM
I really dig the continent shape and the textures look very nice. My only issue is a geometric-looking peninsula in the north west corner. Is this an artificial structure, or just something that generated randomly?
04-09-2012, 02:41 AM
I like the overall color pallet, and the land texture. When zoomed out the blue outline surrounding the continent looks fine, but when you zoom in it is sort of distracting, and doesn't seem to fit well with the overall style of the map. Perhaps it were gradually faded? I don't know. Overall, nice work though.
04-09-2012, 05:10 AM
I say that is beautifully done. The colors and textures are great. You can almost feel the flow of the rivers, nice. Though the blue outline around the continent kinda doesn't fit with the overall map style. I assume it'll be changed maybe. And will you add more details to the map? That would be great. I look forward to any updates.
04-09-2012, 04:19 PM
I agree with what's been said. The continents have an interesting shape and I really enjoy the colors, but the bevel makes the rivers look as though they're floating, and the blue outline is too thick and solid to fit in well. All the same, I'm certainly jealous :)
04-17-2012, 05:53 PM
Hey thanks nice comments :)
Yes I have made some changes, basically re-edited the rivers and the mountains. Also found a way to make the river process a lot easier!
Heres the not yet finished result ( I know some rivers are missing)
The rivers look a lot better now, but try shifting the rivers to about 60-80% opacity, they might work better that way.
I am now going to impart a bit of rare and mysterious lore: to red-green colour-blind people (app. 5-10% of human males) red text on green background looks a) invisible or b) smudged or at least c) quite illegible. To me, red on green just bleeds into everything and it looks utterly, well ... it annoys me no end. The problem is that my "red" photoreceptors are shifted towards the yellow and green parts of the spectrum, so I don't see red that strongly.
Anyhow, red and green are highly contrasting colours and it is a good idea to avoid them, because visually they tend to produce a fuzzy edge, a "bleed" effect, to the human mind - unless you're going for that. Maps generally do not go out of their way to be clashing and visually "arousing" in the sense of making people feel uneasy.
04-21-2012, 06:07 PM
OTOH, as someone with color vision, I find the red text on the forests somewhat more readable than the blue. I guess it depends on whether or not you enjoy messing with the colorblind. ;) Actually, if the map exists in the fictional world it depicts, then a red/green scheme could be a plot point as features of the map would be "hidden" from certain individuals/races.
On the other hand, I am bothered by excess letters in some of the names, like "The Great Forrest". That's find if that's named for Gump, but a collection of trees is a "forest". Likewise, the "Khaali Dessert" may be tasty, but perhaps it should actually be a dry "desert".
04-21-2012, 07:38 PM
Hahaha I see my errors now, thanks for noticing ;)
04-21-2012, 08:50 PM
Hey, your map markers are Zelda symbols! :D
Artistic critique only from me, since I am geography-impaired: personally I think this is quite beautiful, but the texture in the ocean seens a little weird to my eyes; it's very sharply textured, like paint stippling. I guess that could be how an ocean looks from way up in the air (I have no idea! :p) but it just doesn't look all that watery to me. I'd go with something smoother. I guess it does provide a good contrast to the smoother land texture though, so maybe you'd keep it for that reason?
Also, is the island over on the right side using a much higher contrast than the other areas? It looks to me like the textures were applied with different filters, which does make the mountains look sharper but also just generally makes the island look a bitout-of-place compared to the rest. In my opinion anyhow!
Beautiful map would you mind sharing your trade secret for rivers and lakes? I've been struggling with settings to make them smooth and not too harsh.
Powered by vBulletin® Version 4.2.2 Copyright © 2014 vBulletin Solutions, Inc. All rights reserved.