PDA

View Full Version : Lost in mountains!



Ilanthar
05-16-2014, 12:12 PM
I'm planning to re-do my nightfall map (I hope that I don't bother everyone with my multiple remakes btw !), but I can't get a result that satisfies me completely...

Just a reminder : Nightfall is a kind of weird world, and as in a post-apocalyptic world, everything outside cities is strange and weird. I originally wanted to do each mountains zones very differently.

Here are my tests so far : on the right, a drawn version and the middle, the same mountains "redone" digitally.
On the left, two other kind of drawn mountains, more "sharp", dark and more hatched ones.
The digital effect is nice but too "cartoony" to my taste, and the other mountains don't fit really well in ranges...

64133
Any preference? And before all, any advices to improve those or make better ones?

Lingon
05-16-2014, 03:40 PM
I like the middle ones the most actually, but yeah, it's a little cartoony and I guess that's not what you're aiming for here. Of the other styles, I think the top right is my favorite, not sure why actually but it just looks good! Why don't you like how they look in ranges?
I love the forests by the way :)

Ilanthar
05-17-2014, 11:12 AM
By Lingon
but yeah, it's a little cartoony and I guess that's not what you're aiming for here
Exactly, it looks more appropriate for a "warcraft map" than a dark fantasy land...


Why don't you like how they look in ranges?
It lacks of a "barrier" feeling and I suppose it's too "round" compared to what I want (not sure, though, that's hard to explain).


I love the forests by the way
Thanks, that's also a test. I'm doodling on that and may try a forest made of one block (not of single trees).

Ilanthar
05-19-2014, 01:39 PM
Ok, I think I will go with something like this. It has a more "barrier" feeling, imo. And since I dropped the Nightfall remake for another map (that will be useful soon for gaming), so, I may use it for the new one.
64222

What do you think of it?

Schwarzkreuz
05-19-2014, 10:29 PM
Yes, i prefer this not solid shadings more.