PDA

View Full Version : First draft of map for campaign setting (no labels yet).



Nerdling
02-09-2009, 09:04 PM
Title says it all, what do you guys think? I did most of it using techniques I created by modifying existing techniques in RobA's wonderful tut. A lot of it is my own though.

I took the easy way out on the hills/mountains, as you can see.

shpena
02-09-2009, 10:32 PM
Good job mate!

I like the little islands. Keep it up!

bartmoss
02-10-2009, 01:56 AM
Looks good, but I have a problem with either the heights, or some of the rivers. The dark rough patches, to me, look to be mountains and thus higher than the light colored areas. I think this is correct, however that would mean you have rivers flowing from lower areas, to the rough patches, and back to lower areas. Obviously that's not going to work. Maybe I am just confused on what's high and what's low, entirely ossible; if so, a legend would be nice (what ARE those rough patches?) and maybe some better contrast for the colors representing heights. (of course, since I am color blind, this might just be me, so do take that with a grain of salt please.)

Steel General
02-10-2009, 08:12 AM
Great start, look forward to seeing more.

MadLetter
02-10-2009, 08:27 AM
Firstly, the map looks good so far, but let me adress something else...


Maybe I am just confused on what's high and what's low, entirely ossible; if so, a legend would be nice (what ARE those rough patches?) and maybe some better contrast for the colors representing heights. (of course, since I am color blind, this might just be me, so do take that with a grain of salt please.)

I think you are confused ;)

Possibly because of said color blindness. There are brown patches where the rivers spring from, so I think they're meant to be hills/mountains, which would be somewhat confusing, as the rough patches (probably meant to be woodlands) give off a feeling of heigh, but not the mountains. This would probably need to change, lest the map fools more folks...

Try to make the mountains look 3D and not the woods, for the woods there would best be some other filter used, although I do not know which.

Essentially a reversal of the feeling of both mountains and forests would be needed I think.

Other than that, I like the map though. Very good color-choice.

Nerdling
02-10-2009, 01:14 PM
Thanks for the feedback

Yes, the rough patches are supposed to be forests, and the brownish patches are supposed to be mountains/hills.

I think I might try duplicating the bump map layer and applying a blurred mask so It only raises the mountains. That would solve the ambiguity and make it look a lot better. I will probably redo the forest, what I currently have there is sort of a placeholder until I can find a better way of doing it.

PeaceHeather
02-12-2011, 02:00 PM
Okay, sorry to resurrect an old thread, but I had been looking at RobA's mountain tutorial based off this map... and I really want to know how you did the forests! Pleeeeeease? :D
Heather