wow thats a great first try. I agree that the reflection looks funky. I'm pretty sure that the image you have reflected isn't the right perspective, and besides, I think you don't really get reflections at all from a top down angle. Personally I'd say just try making it normal water. Good job experimenting though; thats how you improve Also maybe in the future make the forest shore a bit more distinctive (ie add a beach or something). I think it would work with your scale.