Thread: New Member, Trying to make some decent maps.

Welcome, ninjapenguin !

Placement of human features depends on so very many factors. Scale, sure - the larger the scale (smaller area), the more & smaller items will be shown. But also, WHEN is your setting? What's the culture? An archipelago could do with no roads at all; an underground city could technically be nothing BUT roads :-). The purpose of the map would matter too -- a topographic map or the like could make do with just enough cities and borders to make clear who owns the mountain range, what nations the river connects, and so forth. If 'tis a political map, you may need every settlement above village size. If it's the log of an adventurer, it might have just the places he's passed through.

So -- what's the style you're shooting for, and what's the purpose for your map or maps?

Wow, I may have to have quite a bit of a think about all those questions because some of them I don't actually know the answer to. Thanks for your feedback, it was most enlightening into the sort of things I need to be thinking about.

If you go into worldbuilding, here's a short list of stuff that helps:

astronomy
planetology
geology
meteorology
evolutionary theory
human evolution and physical anthropology
anthropology in general (social, cultural, linguistic too)
archeology
history
geography
sociology
political economy
economy in general

Good job I'm not doing any of those subjects then

So I've done the landscape of my first map. It's not labelled or got any towns/roads on it yet, but I was wondering whether I could get your opinions on it.