March Challenge Voting - Make a 1 Page Dungeon

[timallen]

It was the Lycans den and the Bonny Bard for me. The Bard because I also am one of those suckers for all things piratey, and arsheesh because I sooo wish I could draw like that!

[Cunning Cartographer]

I do find it interesting how the cutout on my Bonny Bard entry seems to be dividing some people; some people like the idea and some people really seem to dislike it (not that I mind, we all have our own tastes). It absolutely wont sway me for editing for my final One Page Dungeon contest entry as I wanted to try something different and, well, I've never seen anyone use part of the page as an actual player prop and I pretty much designed the entire thing with that in mind.

Repped the entries, but can't give it to Arsheesh or Timallen because you guys already had rep from me at some point (I really should start spreading it out more huh...)

[arsheesh]

I do find it interesting how the cutout on my Bonny Bard entry seems to be dividing some people; some people like the idea and some people really seem to dislike it (not that I mind, we all have our own tastes). It absolutely wont sway me for editing for my final One Page Dungeon contest entry as I wanted to try something different and, well, I've never seen anyone use part of the page as an actual player prop and I pretty much designed the entire thing with that in mind.

Repped the entries, but can't give it to Arsheesh or Timallen because you guys already had rep from me at some point (I really should start spreading it out more huh...)

That's OK CC, appreciate the thought. For the record, the cut-out scored points for originality in my book .

Cheers,
-Arsheesh

[fabio p]

Cograts to all the competitors, the choice is almost impossible this month.
Relying on emotional feelings, since I have no remark at all on the great artistic execution of all the finished entries, I’m voting for "Behold the Cliches" by Madcowchef, for the great variety of colourful drawings that awake the child in me, and for “Into the Lycans Den” by arsheesh, for its extremely elegant black and white overall design.

[EricPoehlsen]

I really liked the idea of the cut-out, just not in the center of the page

[Cunning Cartographer]

I really liked the idea of the cut-out, just not in the center of the page

Yeh that's fair enough I went for the cutout being the main component and the adventure revolving around it and the general composition of the page itself, I'm really happy with it either way! From a DM perspective I don't think it matters too much as I personally would print two of the pages anyway, one for the player cutout and one for myself (so that I also have a cutout).

[arsheesh]

Congratulations to timallen for winning this month's challenge with his wonderful Something Lovecraftian entry!

Cheers,
-Arsheesh

[Diamond]

Nice job, Tim!

[Bogie]

Congrats Tim! Well done!

[Cunning Cartographer]

Well done Tim