Please give your honest opinion

[gamefreak651]

My 2 sisters says this map looks kind of like modern earth do you agree with them? any other comments or ideas are also welcomed.

[Ryan K]

I don't agree with them.

[jtougas]

I can see where they would think that. It's close but different enough to be interesting.

[jerriecan]

The continents are laid out vaguely similar, but I'd have to say it's got more in common with a future Earth after many millions of years of continental drift. The Atlantic Ocean is only a sea, the Americas have merged, half of Africa has broken free and Siberia is underwater.

I like it. I can't agree with your sisters, though.

[NeonKnight]

Is it similar? Yes. See the example below:
mapkingdoms copy.png


Is that a bad thing? No. As mentioned above, maybe it is Earth, and Alternate earth a few million years in the past, as can be seen in this link: http://schools.cbe.ab.ca/b813/depts/...contenta1.html


Again, nothing wrong with a fantasy map looking reminiscent of our World. Afterall, the world of Hyborea (Conan the Barbarian's World) sure looks an awful lot like Africa/Middle East/Inda all smooshed together to me.

http://www.google.ca/images?um=1&hl=...&aqi=&aql=&oq=

[RecklessEnthusiasm]

A simple solution would be to flip the map horizontally. I always find myself doodling things with similar land-mass placement to earth, just because it looks right. I always remedy it by just flipping the map horizontally or rotating it 180 degrees.

[gamefreak651]

thanks for your replies i think i will keep this map and finish it.

[tilt]

I'm in agreement, definite similarities but it doesn't really look like earth - to step further away you could move "india" or like RE suggested, flip some elements or the whole map ... nice work

[Nathan]

Ok. So I choose the earth-look-a-like side.
The first time I saw your map, I thought It was an alternate earth map with accelerated continental drift :p