Want some constructive Critizism!

[- Max -]

Didn't you already post this map, it reminds me of something?
Pretty good job for a first map Coastlines looks a bit too computer generated for me, regarding the others lements of the map. Also I'm not sure about east and north-western river flooding but I may be wrong about that. The trunks on isolated trees looks a bit too thick at this scale. Looking forward to see how it will turn

[Jockvonmock]

Yeah i Posted it on the "new member" forum, but the guy replying to me there, told me i should post it here as well for a chance to get more responses. Oh, are u saying i tried to hard on the coastline? becuase it sure is not generated, But maybe u are right, i had another model where the coast were very more round and smooth, but i thought it made the whole island look so small, with alot of curves and bends i generally think it gets a "bigger" look ^^. The flooding? yeah i dont know actually, didnt really have any serious thought behind it. Maybe thats needed for it to look realistic though. And about the trunks, yeah i know they are oversized as H*** but thats very thought through. I like the idea of the trees looking like trees, no matter the scale. I just think it gives a nice look to it. Thanks so much for replying. Means alot.