Results 1 to 3 of 3

Thread: Looking for climate modelling software

Hybrid View

Previous Post Previous Post   Next Post Next Post
  1. #1

    Default

    it's in the cards for my current masterpiece, but i'm sure the results will be far from realistic as i will be satisfied with 'autogenerated' with facility for manual augmentation. ta for the edgcm link

    my sentiment is that realism in simulation is something our referential culture encourages us to believe in, otherwise we wouldn't trust the authority of our academic predecessors, and they wouldn't get paid. irl simulation is much more plausible for small, finite systems. something like a planetwide climate i don't think we can approach given our current means. i'd say you're safe enough to employ a level of imagination and artistry, as science has yet to prove that these things aren't a factor in determining the nature of reality it's probably significantly easier by the 4th or 5th implementation.

  2. #2

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by xoxos View Post
    it's in the cards for my current masterpiece, but i'm sure the results will be far from realistic as i will be satisfied with 'autogenerated' with facility for manual augmentation. ta for the edgcm link

    my sentiment is that realism in simulation is something our referential culture encourages us to believe in, otherwise we wouldn't trust the authority of our academic predecessors, and they wouldn't get paid. irl simulation is much more plausible for small, finite systems. something like a planetwide climate i don't think we can approach given our current means. i'd say you're safe enough to employ a level of imagination and artistry, as science has yet to prove that these things aren't a factor in determining the nature of reality it's probably significantly easier by the 4th or 5th implementation.
    I agree that we can't hope to come up with a perfectly realistic climate model because we don't understand Earth's climate very well yet. Climate science is a relatively young science, and our sample size for Earth-like planets is 1.

    Still, I think it should be quite doable to make a climate model which, with the help of a simple atmospheric circulation model, a simple ocean currents model and a few other basic things, produces plausible Earth-like worlds. Worlds you can look at and say: "Yes, I can believe that an Earth-like world with these continents and oceans would have the climate zones distributed like this."

    If you would like some feedback on the climate generation for your current masterpiece, let me know. I am not a climate scientist, but I know a humble little bit about the subject and might be able to help with an idea or two.

Tags for this Thread

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •