I really like the 3D one.
My players just asked me to draw them one from our game... I hope they're patient.

I can't wait for the color version. I think it would be good of you to use same tone for all the colors: maybe dark one as the pigmentation color of that time period that they get from the plants. Also it could be fun to put the background on an animal skin that the cartographer would have used to create this map.

In any case, continue the great job,
Alucard.