I also voted for SpamValiant on the basis of the most satisfying puzzle.
The Treasure Bay - Carnifex
Do you know the way to Ultima Thule? - Publius
Islands in the endless streams - SpamValiant
The Mermaid Isles - Chel
The Wreck of the Pedeuna Sesitora - helium3
The Legend of Mata-Gara - delgondahntelius
The Melosian Coast - valadaar
The Battle of Damon Bay - RobA
Roan and the Sea Worg - Gamerprinter
Six Sea Birds - rlucci
Tender Thighs, The Captain Lies - Venardhi
I also voted for SpamValiant on the basis of the most satisfying puzzle.
Bryan Ray, visual effects artist
http://www.bryanray.name